East Side Freedom Library’s Statement on Saint Paul Mayor Her’s Recent Encampment Comments

East Side Freedom Library’s Statement on Saint Paul Mayor Her’s Recent Encampment Comments

DaKota Morgan, Housing Justice Organizer | October 29, 2026

The East Side Freedom Library’s Housing Justice Program strongly condemns Mayor Kaohly Her’s continued commitment to clearing homeless encampments as winter approaches, despite the Saint Paul City Council’s unanimous resolution calling for a 60-day, services-first approach.

While elected officials, service providers, community organizations, and advocates support varied solutions and sometimes disagree on approach, we must not lose sight of our shared vision: Every person in Saint Paul deserves a safe, stable place to call home. The intricacies of implementation matter, but they cannot overshadow this fundamental commitment.

At this point, the issue extends beyond disagreements between institutions. Mayor Her’s approach increasingly positions her against a shared vision of Saint Paul where everyone belongs. She has continuously plugged her ears as researchers, service providers, organizers, and most importantly, camp residents, told her that this approach is not a constructive solution, it is simply destruction.

Homelessness does not exist in isolation. It is inseparable from Saint Paul’s long history of neighborhood disinvestment, displacement, rising housing costs, and public policies that simultaneously criminalize poverty while producing the very conditions that perpetuate it.

On the East Side, we understand the consequences of disinvestment. We see them in neglected infrastructure, threatened community spaces, declining affordability, and neighborhoods repeatedly asked to survive without the resources they deserve. These conditions are not disconnected from homelessness. They are part of the same political and economic decisions that determine who has access to stability and who does not.

Yet the narrative surrounding encampments increasingly portrays unhoused residents as dangerous outsiders rather than neighbors who have been displaced. These are human beings who once had places to go, whose lives and communities existed long before they became unhoused.

We cannot continue treating homelessness as an individual moral failure while ignoring the institutional decisions that create and sustain it.

Saint Paul spent approximately $440,000 clearing the Pig’s Eye encampment. The result was not an end to homelessness. Residents were simply displaced into other parts of the city.

Public safety is important, but safety cannot be achieved by repeatedly destroying what little stability people have left.

We must ask ourselves what it means to live in a city where homes can sit empty while people sleep outside. Where public resources can be mobilized to remove people from their communities, but providing deeply affordable housing remains an unmet priority.

Homelessness is not inevitable. It is a consequence of policy decisions, and different decisions are possible.

We call on Mayor Her to halt winter encampment closures, honor the Council’s services-first commitment, and work alongside community organizations, service providers, and people experiencing homelessness to develop meaningful, permanent housing solutions.

We CANNOT continue spending public resources to displace people without addressing why they are unhoused in the first place. When Saint Paul prioritizes removing encampments over creating meaningful pathways to housing, it is not solving homelessness. It is deepening the instability and displacement that have already left so many of our neighbors without a place to call home.

Housing is a human right. Saint Paul must govern accordingly.